Penalty Takers Premier League 2026/27: Who to Buy or Hold

Don't buy the most accurate penalty taker because he tops a conversion ranking; buy only when his role, expected minutes, fixtures and non-penalty involvement justify the cost.
For an existing owner, the threshold is different: an intact role can support patience without making the same player your best available transfer.
This is an evergreen draft for editorial review, not a verified 2026/27 gameweek shortlist, because current prices, clubs, availability, fixtures, deadlines and penalty hierarchies haven't been checked against live official records.
Career Penalty Records Worth Knowing
Career records establish what a player has done, not which player you should buy next.
Player | Penalties scored | Conversion | Record note |
|---|---|---|---|
Alan Shearer | 56 | 86.2% | StatBunker records 56 scored from 65 attempts, with nine misses |
Raúl Jiménez | 14 of 14 | 100% | Best perfect record among players with at least nine attempts |
Yaya Touré | 11 of 11 | 100% | Perfect career record in the cited historical window |
Dimitar Berbatov | 9 of 9 | 100% | Perfect career record in the cited historical window |
Cole Palmer | 18 of 19 | 94.7% | One miss |
Bukayo Saka | 12 of 13 | 92.3% | One miss |
Shearer's row uses the StatBunker all-time penalty table, which records 56 goals from 65 attempts and nine misses, producing the calculated 86.2% conversion rate.
The other rows reflect career outcomes reported by the Premier League on 21 March 2026: Jiménez 14 from 14, Touré 11 from 11, Berbatov nine from nine, Palmer 18 from 19 at 94.7%, and Saka 12 from 13 at 92.3%.
Why Shearer's records need separate denominators
The Premier League's official records identify Shearer as the leading penalty scorer with 56, achieved from 1992/93 to 2005/06, across 14 seasons for Blackburn Rovers and Newcastle United, while also listing 11 misses, jointly with Wayne Rooney.
Those missed-penalty totals don't match the separate statistical table, so combining the official misses with another provider's attempts would create an internally inconsistent conversion calculation.
Keep each source's scored, missed and attempted figures together rather than choosing whichever denominator produces the most persuasive percentage.
What the records actually support
A long record supports confidence that a player has repeatedly held responsibility and executed the task successfully.
A perfect record supports a narrower conclusion: the player converted every recorded attempt in that sample.
Neither establishes current selection, present penalty order or future opportunities.
Record-checking rule: Use historical accuracy to assess execution, then investigate whether the player still has access to the next kick.
The distinction matters when comparing an established taker with a smaller-sample specialist.
The larger sample provides more evidence about execution, but an FPL manager still needs to know whether either player will be on the pitch when an opportunity arrives.
Treat the record as a reason to investigate the role, not as a transfer recommendation.
Penalty Taker Roles and What Each Means for FPL
A penalty role strengthens a transfer case only when the player is the established primary taker and his starts are sufficiently secure.
A backup's possible involvement is upside, not something to pay a transfer premium for before the hierarchy changes.
Classify the responsibility
Role | Who it describes | FPL implication |
|---|---|---|
Primary taker | First choice, with secure starts | Strongest penalty-based case to buy or hold |
Backup taker | Next in line when the primary is absent or substituted | Buy only if the wider case works or the promotion is confirmed |
Shared or rotating taker | Responsibility split by match, venue or circumstance | Reduce the assumed individual share |
Unconfirmed taker | No reliable recent evidence or an unclear order | Don't transfer on penalty status alone |
Record a plausible alternative alongside each primary rather than treating the club's allocation as permanent.
An injury, substitution or selection change can move responsibility without proving that the original taker has permanently lost it.
Separate hierarchy from selection
The primary label describes priority among available teammates; it doesn't promise that the player starts or completes the match.
For a shared arrangement, inspect the circumstances of actual kicks rather than assuming the most recent scorer now owns every future opportunity.
A backup taking a penalty after the primary has left the pitch is evidence of deputy status, not necessarily a promotion.
Use the set-piece responsibility research page as a hierarchy-checking destination, then corroborate the proposed order with completed-match events and official club reporting.
Owned player: Establish whether the role has weakened before making a sale.
Transfer target: Require positive evidence of responsibility rather than an unsupported assumption.
Uncertain arrangement: Keep the player's non-penalty case separate from speculative duties.
No specific 2026/27 gameweek hierarchy has been verified for this draft, so every proposed taker requires an editorial check before publication.
Why Penalties Taken Matter More Than Conversion Rate
A conversion ranking answers how successfully a player finished his recorded penalties, whereas your transfer decision depends on whether he'll receive another opportunity.
The Analyst's examination of Premier League penalty takers illustrates why attempt counts need to sit beside accuracy rather than disappear behind a percentage.
Measure access before execution
Separate penalties taken from penalties scored, and retain the denominator whenever you describe accuracy.
For planning, I'd use penalty access per expected 90 minutes as an editorial framework, not an official FPL statistic.
Build it from the team's penalty-award frequency, the player's expected share of responsibility and the likelihood that he's playing when the award occurs.
Team opportunity: How frequently did the club receive penalties within the chosen completed-match window?
Individual share: Which penalties did the player take while eligible teammates were available?
Pitch access: Was he starting, completing matches or regularly substituted before later opportunities?
A historical attempts-per-90 calculation describes past access, but projecting it requires fresh assumptions about selection and responsibility.
Don't present the historical rate as a measured future probability.
Compare plausible squad choices
Say you're comparing a regularly starting midfielder with established duties against a more accurate forward who rotates.
The forward may be the better penalty finisher, yet the midfielder can remain the stronger purchase if he plays more reliably and contributes more consistently between awards.
That judgement doesn't require pretending the midfielder will receive a penalty in the next match.
A player can be the better taker and still be the worse FPL purchase.
Expected goals and expected assists help assess underlying chance involvement, while derived expected goal involvement per 90 can help compare players with different minutes.
They aren't interchangeable with an FPL points forecast, because selection, scoring rules and the distribution of outcomes still matter.
Calculate historical access for owned players and targets within the same labelled window, then keep recent-form evidence separate from season totals.
Otherwise, you risk comparing one player's brief spell as primary taker with another's entire campaign as a deputy.
Which Clubs Win the Most Penalties
Penalty goals aren't the same measure as penalties won, so a club scoring leaderboard cannot directly answer which attack receives the most awards.
The Premier League club penalty-goals page associated with the 2025/26 window lists Manchester City on 77, Arsenal on 71, Manchester United on 69 and Liverpool on 63, but these displayed totals require filter and scope verification before they can be treated as season-specific evidence.
Club | Penalty goals displayed against the 2025/26 window | Caveat |
|---|---|---|
Manchester City | 77 | Team penalty goals, not awards or individual attempts |
Arsenal | 71 | Team penalty goals, not awards or individual attempts |
Manchester United | 69 | Team penalty goals, not awards or individual attempts |
Liverpool | 63 | Team penalty goals, not awards or individual attempts |
Capture date is unverified, so these figures must not be published as confirmed single-season totals or used as a current-season ranking without checking the live table.
Compare the right team measure
For transfer analysis, collect penalties awarded separately from goals scored, because conversion changes the latter without changing the former.
Use a consistent competition and completed-match window across clubs.
A team can accumulate penalty goals through different takers, so even a reliable historical club total doesn't establish the present player's share.
Check team context through the club-statistics comparison page, with particular attention to filters and whether the displayed measure records awards, attempts or goals.
Apply volume without overpaying
A slightly less accurate taker at a club receiving more opportunities can plausibly outscore a perfect finisher who rarely takes a kick.
That comparison only helps when both players' minutes and underlying attacking involvement are acceptable.
For a purchase: Confirm that the target receives the club's opportunities.
For an existing holding: Judge whether a quiet spell reflects fewer awards or a genuine loss of responsibility.
For a forecast: Refresh the window rather than carrying an old team rate into a new campaign unchanged.
Team volume supplies context, not ownership of future points.
What Can Change a Penalty After It Is Awarded
A saved penalty may not remain a saved penalty: under IFAB Law 14, the goalkeeper must have at least part of one foot touching, level with or behind the goal line when the ball is kicked, and an offence affecting a missed or saved kick can require a retake.
A scored penalty normally stands despite that goalkeeper offence, which is why the first live event isn't always the final statistical outcome.

Count the settled sequence
An event feed can initially show a save, then a retake, then a goal.
An analyst should group those entries by match and penalty sequence instead of treating every line as an independent team opportunity.
Penalties awarded: The settled decisions giving the team a kick.
Penalties taken: The player's officially recorded attempts under the dataset's classification.
Penalty goals: The final credited goals from those attempts.
Keep rebound goals separate from penalty conversions.
The kicker can play a rebound from the goalkeeper, but cannot immediately play a rebound from the post or crossbar unless another player has touched the ball.
Review can change the interpretation
The Premier League's penalty-decision explanation states that every awarded penalty is automatically checked, including possible attacking infringements in the possession phase leading to the decision.
The league's updated law guidance assigns goalkeeper-encroachment monitoring solely to VAR from 2025/26.
The Premier League's penalty-kick guidance also distinguishes player encroachment that materially affects the outcome from encroachment that doesn't.
These distinctions matter on both sides of an FPL squad.
A goal that stands removes the defending side's clean sheet, while a provisional save shouldn't be treated as a settled goalkeeper return before the final event and scoring update.
Don't target a goalkeeper because of an isolated penalty save, and don't sell a reliably starting defender solely because his side conceded an isolated spot-kick.
The useful evidence is the settled event plus the player's wider role, not the initial live notification.
What a Penalty Taker Is Worth Without a Penalty
Remove the hypothetical spot-kick from your transfer argument and ask whether you'd still want the player.
If the answer is no, you're paying for an event whose timing you can't establish.
Separate the sources of uncertainty
Penalty duty isn't a permanent points bonus, even when responsibility is undisputed.
Assess the components independently rather than merging them into a single confident label.
Role certainty: Does the player have priority over available teammates?
Penalty frequency: Does the team receive enough opportunities in the relevant window?
Conversion: How successfully has the player finished his recorded attempts?
Decision volatility: Could review alter the award or final outcome?
A securely selected primary taker can go through a fixture run without receiving a kick.
During that spell, his practical value comes from minutes, shots, chance creation and other routes to FPL scoring.
Test the open-play alternative
Compare the target with an affordable player who doesn't take penalties but offers a stronger combination of starts and attacking involvement.
If the penalty taker costs more, identify what you're sacrificing elsewhere in your squad to fund him.
Use the attacking-statistics comparison page to frame the non-penalty assessment, keeping chance involvement distinct from a points prediction.
Budget test: Don't weaken a reliable starting position elsewhere merely to buy speculative penalty upside.
An owner can reasonably tolerate a penalty drought when the player remains a sound selection without spot-kicks.
A new purchase needs a stronger marginal case, particularly when it requires a points hit or blocks a more urgent injury replacement.
Any quoted frequency should identify its season, gameweek range and capture date, rather than implying an old award rate remains current.
When to Buy, Hold or Avoid a Penalty Taker
Penalty duty is role-based upside, not a guaranteed return, and buying requires a stronger case than retaining a player already in your squad.
The transfer uses a scarce squad-management opportunity and may carry an immediate points cost.
Match the action to the evidence
Situation | New buy | Owned player | Re-check trigger |
|---|---|---|---|
Secure starts and established primary role | Buy if fixtures are acceptable and the price fits | Hold through a scoring drought | A new taker is named |
Backup taker with uncertain minutes | Avoid a transfer premium | Hold only if the wider minutes case remains sound | Next confirmed line-up |
Single incident or unverified hierarchy change | Avoid a points hit | Don't sell on that event alone | Confirmed club reporting |
Penalty retaken or removed after review | Don't pay for the provisional outcome | Retain if the underlying role stands | Final official event |
A change of taker is more meaningful when both players were available and the previous primary remained on the pitch.
Even then, distinguish a permanent instruction from an unexplained isolated decision.
Don't spend a transfer merely to resolve uncertainty that official reporting may clarify before the deadline.
Price the alternative transfer
For a new buy, compare the target with the player you'd otherwise select at that price and position.
Include the effect on your remaining budget, bench cover and planned response to injuries.
For an owner, compare holding against the actual replacement rather than against an idealised list of penalty specialists.
An injury-related chance-of-playing flag doesn't guarantee a start, so returning availability alone shouldn't settle the decision.
Buy conditionally: The role is established, starts look secure, fixtures are acceptable and the wider attacking case supports the price.
Hold selectively: The player remains useful in your starting side and there's no confirmed deterioration in role.
Avoid the hit: The argument rests mainly on a recent penalty incident or a presumed promotion.
Captaincy needs a higher level of conviction because you're concentrating more of your gameweek outcome in that player.
Use penalty duty as supporting evidence after assessing the likely start, fixture and attacking involvement, not as the sole reason to give him the armband.
A nominal taker with unresolved fitness or selection doubts is not a safer captain merely because his career conversion looks impressive.
How to Verify the Penalty Role Before Your Deadline
A reliable deadline check starts with the player's current identity and selection situation, not with a historical penalty leaderboard.
For this draft, the target gameweek and capture date remain unverified, so no named player should be presented as a confirmed current recommendation.
Build a reproducible check
Confirm the current player details using official Fantasy Premier League records for club, price, FPL position and availability, because an old profile or historical club association can invalidate the comparison.
Read official club reporting for injuries, training updates and any explicit statement about penalty responsibility, distinguishing a confirmed change from an analyst's inference.
Separate minutes windows into the completed season sample and a clearly labelled recent-form sample, without adding overlapping periods together.
Inspect the forthcoming fixture run, checking the next three gameweeks for planning while using official expected points only for the single next gameweek they cover.
Review completed penalty sequences and confirm the settled official outcome after review or a retake before updating the player's responsibility record.
Record the scope beside each metric, including season, target gameweek, capture date and statistical window, with live-gameweek events kept separate from completed-match analysis.
Remove unsuitable candidates using position, price, minutes and availability filters before deciding whether penalty responsibility changes the final shortlist.
Keep forecasts and access claims precise
Our player prices, points, ownership, form, transfers and expected statistics come from official Fantasy Premier League data.
Our next-gameweek expected-points value is supplied by FPL and used unchanged, rather than extended into an unsupported forecast across several fixtures.
A player who passes the budget filter can still fail the minutes test, and a likely starter can still fail the current-role check.
If the hierarchy remains unclear, mark it for editorial verification instead of naming the player as a confirmed taker.
Only act when the verified role, likely minutes and fixture context support the same decision.
Before your deadline, open your owned players' and shortlisted targets' free individual profiles, then use Differential Picks, Budget Picks or Form Plus Next Fixture where ownership, affordability or the immediate fixture helps settle the comparison.
Those resources are free, while the other 14 maps and nine FPL tools are paid TFA member resources; check current access before relying on a particular research route, and make the transfer only if the player still earns his place without assuming a penalty arrives.


